Four brief thoughts on developments in Kashmir

I suppose everyone has seen the news on Kashmir. I have some thoughts.

1. I don't know if the internet as we know it will exist in ten years, or whether I will still be alive at the time, but I feel reasonably comfortable making the following prediction: strictly seen from the perspective of maintaining the current territorial status quo in Kashmir, the Indian state will come to regret this decision within a decade. Even if it holds on to the state in its entirety, it just made its job a lot tougher and costlier. I also think it has opened up wiggle room -- diplomatically and legally -- that did not exist before.

2. Relatedly, I believe no institution is happier today than GHQ. No, not even the RSS or Times Now or Republic TV. Congrats to Modi and Amit Shah for doing more for Pakistan's position than anyone in Pindi could have hoped for. There's a dissertation and a half waiting to be written on popular right wing nationalism at home leading to dumb and overreaching shit abroad (I can think of some recent cases).

3. Anyone in Delhi or DC or on anywhere else who tries to pin this on any "external threat" should never be paid attention to again. Trust me, I'm more than aware of the times when Pakistan's behavior has been key to how India behaves in Kashmir, but this time ain't it. I've seen some hilarious tweets in this regard but this probably takes the cake

This is basically geopolitical mad libs. May as well add climate change and North Korea to the mix as well while we're at it. The "external threat assessment," objectively speaking, has actually been trending the other way:

Yeah so guys, sorry, but this is ALL domestic politics. It's a combination of the mandate the BJP perceived/received in the recent elections and the fact that the Hindutva right has been talking about 370/35-A for a long time. As I told Zafar Aafaq (Kashmir Life journalist) in an interview a couple years ago
There is the Indian domestic angle. When Modi came to power, the big question was, would he try to satisfy his Hindutva base or go for the economic reforms. It is pretty clear now that he chose to burnish its social cultural Hindutva base which is extremely intolerant of any concession to Kashmir. They want to take back old concessions like Article 370 and 35-A rather than giving new concession. So I don’t think this government in Delhi is in any mood to concede anything to Kashmir.
 They finally got what it wanted. But going back to 1, be careful what you wish for, fellas.

4. There is a rabidity on Kashmir on the Indian right and even mainstream that is, to put it mildly, unsettling (and no, this is not just about Anupam Kher's tweets). I really hope there's something resembling a leash put on security forces behavior in the next few weeks because there exist plausible scenarios where things get pretty bad. Not necessarily likely, but definitely plausible. 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

On the cancelled LUMS conference and the noxious Ejaz Haider

Image
It is a terribly sad indictment that LUMS was compelled to cancel it's (online) conference on the 1971 war and genocide. When I first learned of the conference on Twitter, I was pleasantly surprised. An open and honest discussion of the war? That's great!  The School of Humanities and Social Sciences,LUMS, in collaboration with the National Institute of Pakistan Studies (NIPS),Quaid-i-Azam University, is organizing an online conference to commemorate the fiftieth anniversary of the Bangladesh War of Liberation. Here's the schedule: pic.twitter.com/oOqRN1SUgA — Ali Usman Qasmi (@AU_Qasmi) March 19, 2021 More than that, while the association of those damn pinkos at LUMS was to be expected -- if something like this was going to happen, you can bet it would involve them in some capacity -- the fact of QAU also being involved was interesting. For better or worse, I interpreted their involvement as a tacit nod from the powers that be that this was okay. And if it was okay, how
Read more

Eight scenarios for the 2018 elections

Image
There has been considerable concern about the level of engineering behind these elections. Which is of course fair enough. Nevertheless, it bears mentioning that the outcome of this election is still technically up in the air. This is not a Stalin or Saddam style rigging project. As much as GHQ has tilted the playing field in the last few months, Pakistani voters still exercise agency . The generals have had their say, but on July 25, the people get a go. While it is reasonable to surmise that the establishment's efforts have made the entire thing foreordained, I think there's still some grey area, if only because we know (hope?) that full-blown ballot stuffing and miscounting of votes is not on the cards. With that in mind, I've tried to think through a few educated guesses of what the world may look like. Before I lay those out, some major caveats: 1. The data is limited, both in how much there is and how good it is 2. Even if the data were great, no one
Read more

Three thoughts on the situation in Kashmir

Sometimes standing still is the best move Football fans will be aware of la pausa , which refers to the revolutionary act of slowing down, or even standing still, in the midst of the helter skelter of a football match. The idea is to either let a teammate get in a better position for a pass or to improve the angle of a pass by letting your defender move. You can see a great example below, from the 2014 World Cup quarter final between Argentina and Belgium. Watch Messi receive the ball, scamper forward as if he is going to go on one of his crazy runs, then slow down, almost stop, and then play the pass. That pause is to allow Di Maria to make the run down the right. What does this have to do with Kashmir? The point is, sometimes standing still or doing nothing is the best move. I believe it was Napoleon who said that when your opponent is making a mistake, you should let him. That's exactly the situation Pakistan finds itself in right now. India has made a pretty big blund
Read more